How Much Student Loan Debt Is Too Much? A Breakdown by Degree
When it comes to college, there’s one number students and parents fear almost as much as tuition itself: student loan debt. With rising costs and stagnant wages, it’s no surprise that millions of Americans are asking the same question: how much student loan debt is too much?
The answer isn’t one-size-fits-all — it depends heavily on what degree you’re pursuing, what your post-graduation salary might be, and how manageable your monthly payments will be. In this article, we’ll break it down by degree level to help you figure out what’s reasonable and what might be a financial red flag.
🎓 First, Let’s Talk Numbers: The Average Student Loan Debt in the U.S.
Before diving into specifics by degree, here’s a snapshot of the current landscape:
-
Average student loan debt (undergraduate): $28,950 per borrower
-
Total U.S. student loan debt (2024): Over $1.7 trillion
-
Monthly average payment (standard plan): $300–$400
These numbers are enough to make anyone uneasy. But the truth is, some degrees justify more debt than others — and some don’t at all.
💡 The Golden Rule: Debt Shouldn’t Exceed Your Expected First-Year Salary
A commonly recommended benchmark is this:
“Never borrow more than what you expect to earn in your first year after graduation.”
This isn’t a hard rule, but it helps prevent future hardship. If your expected starting salary is $45,000, you should aim for no more than $45,000 in total student debt. Anything higher might become unmanageable.
📘 Breakdown by Degree Type
Let’s explore how this rule applies across different degree paths.
1. Associate’s Degree (2-Year Programs)
Typical debt: $10,000–$20,000
Average starting salary: $30,000–$45,000
Is it worth it?
Yes, if you keep debt low. Community colleges and technical schools tend to be more affordable. Many students who earn an associate degree in nursing, HVAC, dental hygiene, or IT support can start earning good salaries relatively quickly.
Tips:
-
Consider working part-time to avoid borrowing.
-
Explore state grants and scholarships.
-
Use this degree as a stepping stone to a bachelor’s without incurring too much debt.
Verdict: Keep debt under $20,000 to stay safe.
2. Bachelor’s Degree (4-Year Programs)
Typical debt: $25,000–$50,000
Average starting salary: $45,000–$60,000
Popular majors: Business, Psychology, Education, Engineering
Is it worth it?
It depends on your major. A bachelor’s degree in computer science or engineering might lead to a $70,000+ starting salary, which justifies higher debt. But a degree in liberal arts or education might come with lower initial earnings.
Tips:
-
Choose in-state public universities to cut costs.
-
Max out federal loans before going private.
-
Estimate your future earnings before accepting aid.
Verdict: Try to keep debt below $40,000 unless your major commands a high salary.
3. Master’s Degree
Typical debt: $30,000–$80,000+
Average starting salary increase: $10,000–$25,000 more than a bachelor’s
Popular fields: Business (MBA), Social Work, Public Health, Education
Is it worth it?
It can be, but this is where many borrowers overspend. If your master’s program doesn’t guarantee a substantial salary bump, think twice before borrowing large amounts.
For example:
-
A Master’s in Social Work might only offer $50,000 starting pay, making $80,000 in loans unreasonable.
-
On the flip side, an MBA that leads to six figures in finance or tech might justify $80,000+ in debt.
Tips:
-
Attend a public university or online program.
-
Ask your employer if they offer tuition reimbursement.
-
Research ROI before enrolling.
Verdict: Your debt should be no more than 1x your post-master’s salary. For most, that means staying under $60,000.
4. Professional Degrees (Law, Medicine, Dentistry)
Typical debt:
-
Law school: $100,000–$160,000
-
Medical school: $200,000–$250,000
-
Dental school: $250,000–$300,000
Starting salaries:
-
Lawyers: $65,000–$150,000 (varies widely)
-
Doctors: $200,000–$300,000+
-
Dentists: $150,000–$250,000
Is it worth it?
Often, yes — but not always. The key here is career certainty and school reputation.
A top-10 law school may land you a BigLaw job with a six-figure salary. But a lower-tier law school might leave you with $150,000 in debt and no job. For medical and dental students, the high debt is often justified by extremely high and stable salaries, even if it takes years to pay off.
Tips:
-
Avoid expensive private schools if you’re not going into a high-paying specialty.
-
Consider income-driven repayment or forgiveness programs.
-
Don’t borrow without a detailed repayment plan.
Verdict: This is the only category where six-figure debt may be okay — but only with a solid job outlook.
🚨 Red Flags That You’re Borrowing Too Much
-
You need private loans before exhausting federal aid.
-
Your loan payments will exceed 10–15% of your take-home pay.
-
You’re not sure what job you’ll get after graduating.
-
You’re borrowing to attend a for-profit college.
-
You don’t have a plan to repay or consolidate.
✅ Smart Borrowing Tips for Students and Families
-
Always max out scholarships and grants first.
-
Work during college to minimize how much you borrow.
-
Use Net Price Calculators on college websites to estimate actual costs.
-
Start with a community college or in-state school.
-
Avoid lifestyle inflation — borrowing more just to live comfortably now will hurt you later.
🧠 Final Thoughts: Know Before You Owe
Student loans aren’t inherently bad. In fact, they’ve allowed millions of Americans to access education and opportunities they wouldn’t have otherwise. But debt without strategy is dangerous.
Don’t go into debt blindly. Do your research. Know your major’s expected salary. Use financial calculators. And always ask yourself: “Will my future self thank me for this decision?”
Because ultimately, how much debt is too much?
It’s the amount that limits your freedom, delays your dreams, or keeps you up at night.
Make sure you borrow for a degree that gives back — not one that holds you back.
